One of my goals for 2016 was to grow my reader email list – by a lot. I started the year with a list of 135 reader emails, and my goal was to add 7,500 new emails, while making sure those new emails were my target reader. As you can imagine, that goal would require a lot of focus and hard work!
I ended the year with a total of 7,313 subscribers on my fiction reader list, which means a net increase of 7,178 emails. Not quite my goal, but close enough I was happy. Of course, those don’t include people who have unsubscribed as I’ve sent emails to the list throughout the year (because those unsubscribes weren’t my target reader, right?), nor does it double-count people who have subscribed through multiple ways. (I use Groups in Mailchimp and consolidate all my reader emails to separate groups within a single list, so no email is duplicated. Otherwise, that would be a sure way to spam someone!)
I’ve talked about the importance of doing a postmortem for a book launch, so as I set my email list growth goals for 2017, I thought it might be helpful to see what efforts produced the best (and worst) results in 2016. The open and click rates for each category below are from the campaign I just sent on 12/27/16 for my new release, so it should be a fairly equal comparison.
Here’s the list:
• Organic sign-ups: 345 emails
Open rate: 61.6%. Click rate: 22.4%.
This is people who sign-up for my mailing list through links in the back of my books, my website, or social media profiles. These people have not received anything in exchange for signing up, except an excited welcome email from me. 🙂
• Sign-ups to receive my free short story that goes after book 5 in my Mountain Dreams Series: 506 emails
Open rate: 33.3%. Click rate: 11.1%.
This offer is in the back of all my ebooks and has a special page on my website. I don’t promote it anywhere else, because it’s helpful to have read that series to appreciate the short story.
• Facebook Lead Generation ads promoting my permafree, book 1 in the Mountain Dreams Series: 4,077 emails
Open rate: 26.1%. Click rate: 8%.
I’ve run these throughout most of the year at a low budget, usually between $5-7/day. I haven’t blogged specifically about this type of FB ad, but I plan to when time permits. It’s my favorite for mailing list growth for many reasons, including the fact that it’s great at helping authors narrow down their target audience and find pertinent keywords. I have a 3-email automation sequence that goes out to new sign-ups giving them the free book in email #1. Then email #2 gives the first few pages of book #2 in that series, along with the link to buy. Then email #3 announces my newest release. So I use these ads as a tool for both list growth and book sales.
• Ongoing Instafreebie giveaway for my permafree book. 835 emails
These were harder to get exact open and click rates because of the way I was tracking subscribers from Instafreebie. From what I can tell, it looks the open and click rates were approx. 33% and 11% respectively.
I blogged about the Instafreebie giveaway here. I was a little skeptical about how high the open and click rates would be, but I’ve been pleasantly surprised.
• Instafreebie group giveaway for my permafree book: 812 emails
Open and click rates appear to be similar to Instafreebie above.
This was a group of 8 authors who write Christian fiction in a variety of genres. Potential readers chose which (if any) author they wanted to follow in exchange for receiving that author’s free book. The giveaway was done right before Christmas, which is not always a time people are focused on reading or seeking out new books. I have a suspicion it may have been even better right after Christmas. I’m pleased with the results, though!
• Fall Author Mailing List Promo organized by Ryan Zee of BookSweeps: 603 emails
Open rate: 56.8%. Click rate: 19.3%.
This was geared toward fans of Inspirational historical romance (my specific genre), and I was really pleased with the outcome. Ryan’s team gave great ideas to the authors for how to onboard the sign-ups, and I had great interaction with the new readers. It was interesting to find that some of them were already on my list or had sent me reader emails previously. That goes to show this method of recruiting email address is successfully reaching my target audience. Ryan is doing another of these in the spring, and I’m already signed up. There are other similar services out there, but Ryan’s has the best targeting for my specific genre.
In a postmortem, my next step would be to analyze what I would change and what I definitely want to repeat. I won’t bore you with those details, but here’s a chance for you to analyze whether you’d like to try anything from this list!
And I’d love to hear from you now! Did you try any other approaches to growing your reader email list this year that I haven’t mentioned here? If so, what were the results? Or maybe you’ve tried something I did. If so, I’d love to hear about it!
Want real email examples and pro tips to set up your Welcome Email Sequence? Get these and more in my new course!